Vrede wrote:O Really wrote:FBI shoots 150 people in 20 years? Is that a good or bad number? The Jax Florida cops have already shot 10 just this year already, and average more than 25 a year, leading the state and on a per capita basis possibly the nation. Not that I believe all internal "investigations" of shootings, rarely having seen one that found the cop was just a hothead, but still...
Your point about internal "investigations" - including in this case the "justifiable" determination despite forking over $1.3 million "to the victim of a 2002 FBI shooting, an innocent 20-year-old the FBI mistook for a bank robber" - is more the reason I posted it than the 150 tally.
If this is how their internal "controls" <ahem> work when people are shot what's the logical conclusion about their other less visible activities?
"Justified" vs. "liable" isn't the same thing. At issue regarding "justified" would be whether the agent took reasonable action and in accordance with protocol in the situation he had. At issue regarding "liable" would be that he shot the wrong guy. Even if your investigation found the agent to be an incompetent dolt, the shooting could still be considered "justified" if the incompetent dolt had a reasonable belief at the time that the guy was a robber. (oversimplified example: if a guy with a mask on comes running out of a bank, a cop might be more likely to believe he's a robber than a guy late for a Halloween party.)
In the brief time I was willing to spend on it, I didn't find a summary of the alleged $1.3 million settlement or what the facts and circumstances were. So I don't know if, IMNVHO, I would have counted it "justified." But it could have been and they still could be liable for having shot the wrong guy.
Personally, I generally rave about "unjustified" in instances where there were other available alternatives, and where a reasonably trained cop should have taken one of those alternatives.
But discussing this certainly should make one think if they really want to be the "civilian" armed and waving his "defensive" gun in a crowd when a criminal starts shooting.